The Arc of a Cult: From Birth to Breakdown

We like to think we’d see it coming. We like to think we’d never fall for it. But history shows how easily belief can become a cage and how slowly the door closes.

Jul 15, 2025

During the early 90s, a strange bulletin arrived at our house from a farm co-op near San Antonio. This zine briefly captivated us, its art gritty, but oddly idyllic, the message ecologically focused yet strangely apocalyptic. It promised clarity, community, and a path to something better. As burgeoning tweens and teens, we were mesmerized, yet somehow knew to keep the papers referencing the “deathaculture” hidden. We wrote to them a few times, and for a while, their writings arrived in our mailbox like little seeds of another world. Looking back, I realize how lucky we were to have only flirted with it, and how familiar their message seems now, in so many other forms.

Cults don’t emerge out of nowhere. They follow an ancient, predictable arc, from birth to breakdown, shaped by the same vulnerabilities, the same fears, and the same human need to belong. We’ve seen it before. We’re seeing it again. And often, they don’t lead to a dark hippy commune with questionable ideas, but rather to growing groups of disenfranchised and sometimes militant people who are desperate to believe in something, anything, other than what their life has given them.

We just hit 17,000 subscribers—thank you!

Get exclusive access for just $1/week or $52 a year.

Get exclusive analysis and fearless reporting you won’t find in corporate media.

The Spark: Origins

Almost every cult begins with a charismatic figure and a simple promise.

In moments of political, economic, or spiritual crisis, when people feel disillusioned and abandoned, someone steps forward to say: Only I can fix it. Father Divine offered that message during the Great Depression. Jim Jones emerged in the chaos of the 1970s. David Koresh found his voice in the confusion of the 1980s.

These leaders rarely start by naming specific enemies or making wild demands. They start by naming your pain. They tell you it’s not your fault. They offer clarity and belonging, and hint at an enemy lurking in the shadows.

And then they begin to build.

The Build: Formation

Once a leader gathers a core of believers, the walls begin to rise.

At first, the line between “us” and “them” is blurry, just vague talk of betrayal and corruption, a culture that is losing its way, or is rife with sin. Soon, however, the leader sharpens it, undermining trust in education, government, media, and even family. Followers are told you are not to blame. They did this to you. Every grievance, from loneliness, failure, and humiliation, is hung like a medal on the chest of the group, and a scapegoat is found to explain it all.

Alongside this emotional divide comes a physical and psychological one. Followers are encouraged to cut off dissenting voices, leave their families, and abandon old friends. They move into communes, wear uniforms, and shave their heads. Moonies staged mass weddings in identical gowns and suits. Heaven’s Gate donned identical tracksuits. Upon their body, they display a badge that identifies them as belonging to the group. For most of history, isolation meant a compound or a farm. Today, believers can exist anywhere — and everywhere — at once.

In this separation, an ideology is formed, and with it, the propaganda arm emerges. In the digital age, some movements go beyond pamphlets or videos. Instead, they build entire platforms. What once required mimeographed bulletins and street-corner evangelists now thrives on bespoke social networks and forums. Truth Social, Gab, and Parler became echo chambers where dissenting voices are drowned out and the leader’s word remains unchallenged. Anonymous forums like 4chan and 8kun incubated QAnon conspiracies, turning memes into scripture and hashtags into holy writ. These spaces not only spread the message but also reinforce the isolation. Followers are encouraged to trust only what’s inside the bubble, just as they once were told to burn newspapers and shun television. The medium has changed, but the tactic — controlling the information diet — remains the same.

The Peak: Power, Theater, & Contradictions

At its height, the cult feels invincible. The leader is untouchable.

“Miracles” are staged to confirm the leader’s special status. Often it is surviving attacks — physical or verbal, predicting crises, or claiming victories against impossible odds. No one else could have done this, the leader says. And to the followers, this is proof of their divine nature, or their righteousness and rightness.

These miracles are never just events; they’re theater. They are redramatized, their locations becoming holy places, the damage a testament to the divinity of the mission. Bullet holes in Waco became sacred scars. Tapes of Jim Jones’s healings were replayed like scripture. Bandages and shrines served as constant proof of divine favor, not just for the leader, but for the group as a whole.

It isn’t enough just to believe. Followers are expected to evangelize, to defend the faith against outsiders. Their role may be to sell flowers, post leaflets, post hashtags, and “red-pill” strangers online. The act of proselytizing becomes both a performance and a ritual, deepening their own belief as they try to convert others.

At this stage, financial control also tightens. The badges and items that define them must be purchased to signify belonging. All aspects of their identity become rooted in the group, from clothing and adornment to their possessions. Before long, followers sign over their paychecks, work long hours for free, and sell their homes. Economic dependency cements psychological dependency.

And through it all, the leader begins testing boundaries. At first, the rules seem pure and noble, but little by little, exceptions are made. Hypocrisy seeps in, so gradually that followers barely notice. Soon, the leader is sleeping with members’ wives, taking underage girls as “brides,” or living in luxury while preaching poverty, and the followers twist themselves into knots to justify it.

The Cracks: Fracture

But reality always comes knocking.

Predictions fail. Utopias don’t arrive. The leader’s perfection is questioned. Finally, there is a hypocrisy too glaring to ignore.

Inside the group, paranoia grows. Followers are made to confess imagined sins. “Purges” are staged to root out supposed traitors. Public humiliation becomes a tool to keep everyone in line. Those who doubt are exiled, branded enemies, or worse.

In Waco, Koresh humiliated doubters publicly. In QAnon communities, influencers are accused of being “plants” and cast out to keep the flock afraid and obedient. To even be accused is enough to taint their image within the group.

Sometimes, an alternative voice begins to emerge. Perhaps for a while, the two speak as one. But eventually, there is a falling out, a disconnect. Loyalties become divided. The group begins to eat itself.

The Fall: Collapse or Mutation

When the leader falls through death, arrest, or scandal, the group often splinters.

Some followers leave in waves, traumatized and disoriented. Some double down and regroup. Many struggle to reintegrate into the outside world, still haunted by the belief that once gave their lives meaning.

The Branch Davidians, already a splinter of a splinter, fractured again after Koresh’s fiery death at Waco, yet remnants still exist today. Heaven’s Gate ended in mass suicide, but its writings still circulate online. QAnon fragmented after failed prophecies, yet persists in countless digital echo chambers.

Belief rarely dies cleanly. It mutates, finding new forms, new platforms, and, sometimes, new names.

Why It Works: Why They Stay

Cults prey on the vulnerable — not because they’re weak— but because they’re human.

Loneliness, disillusionment, trauma, and alienation are all universal experiences. Cults exploit them, offering certainty, belonging, and someone else to blame. They strip you down, perhaps through sleep deprivation, confession, or public shaming, and then rebuild you in their image.

And yet, people do escape. Survivors rebuild their lives, sometimes becoming outspoken critics or guides for others. Even after Jonestown, a handful of survivors dedicated themselves to helping others heal. Even after NXIVM, former members found the strength to testify and walk free.

Share The Coffman Chronicle

A Final Warning

If you’ve read this far, you’ve seen the pattern.

You’ve seen how movements start with idealism and belonging, and end in paranoia, hypocrisy, and ruin. You’ve seen how leaders creep from charisma to cruelty, how walls rise slowly, how belief hardens into a cage.

You’ve seen how the outside world becomes the enemy.

And you’ve seen how technology has only accelerated the cycle, building not just leaflets and zines, but entire platforms and echo chambers where doubt is betrayal, enemies are everywhere, and the leader’s word is law.

History whispers: We’ve been here before.

Have you seen these patterns in a movement, a workplace, or an online community? What helped you or others break free? Share your thoughts in the comments below.